How to evaluate the effectiveness of telemedicine?
October 2, 2021How Can Remote Patient Monitoring Improve Healthcare?
November 15, 2021- The COVID-19 pandemic has accelerated the uptake of telemedicine, particularly for mental healthcare.
- The delivery of mental health services remotely via electronic and digital communication devices is often called telemental health or e-mental health.
- This article will discuss the use of, evidence for effectiveness of telemedicine for psychiatry and behavioural health, and guidelines for best practice.
Mental health is one of the most promising applications of telemedicine. Video consultations for mental health are increasing, and constitute a large proportion of teleconsultations. A recent survey in California found that 48.3% of all telemedicine visits were for psychiatry or behavioural health.
Telemental health care delivery models
Models for remote delivery of mental health care:
- Patients may consult with a mental health specialist through telemedicine services located at local hospitals or primary care clinics
- Direct consultation, via an internet connected device from the patient’s home
- The use of mobile applications for symptom tracking, remote management and self-care
Each method may be suited for different situations or individuals and used in combination.
Why is telemedicine particularly suited to mental health?
Mental health visits usually involve less hands-on procedures – such as physical examination, blood tests and imaging – than other specialities. Many types of mental health assessments and talking therapies are ideally suited to telemedicine. When used appropriately telemedicine visits have the potential to achieve the same diagnostic and therapeutic functionalities as in-person visits.
What are the benefits of telemedicine in mental health?
- Convenience – The convenience of telemedicine may be especially beneficial for individuals who find in-person appointments difficult due to work, caregiving responsibilities, physical or psychological challenges.
- Improved access – Telemedicine improves access to mental healthcare professionals, as geographical distance is eliminated. It may also help extend capacity where there is a shortage of mental health professionals.
- Continuity of care – Patients are less likely to miss appointments and can also access help and advice more quickly if they are experiencing difficulties. This has great potential to improve outcomes for mental healthcare treatment.
- Efficiency savings – Remote mental healthcare delivery can reduce overheads and enable more efficient use of clinical resources. Patients save time and travel costs by seeing their therapist virtually.
- Home-based care – Many patients feel more at ease in their home environment. They may worry about being seen going to a psychiatric office due to fear of being stigmatized. Teleconsultations may also provide doctors with insights into living conditions which may impact patients’ health.
- Empowering self-care – Mobile apps and other media can be used to motivate and empower patients to monitor and look after their own mental health.
What challenges are associated with the use of telemedicine?
- Privacy concerns – Confidentiality and privacy of conversations and sensitive patient data must be ensured.
- Offscreen distractions – There may be noise and distractions during videoconsulations.
- Reduced nonverbal cues – It may be more difficult for clinicians to pick up on non-verbal cues during virtual visits.
- Technical issues and usability – Both clinicians and patients should be comfortable using the technology. The appropriate infrastructure and connectivity should be in place.
- Licensing and insurance issues – Providers must stay up to date with local regulations on the use of telemedicine.
- Safety issues – Clinical judgement must be used to decide whether telemedicine is appropriate in each case. Protocols for obtaining informed consent and handling emergencies must be in place.
The use of remote digital care provision is complementary to, but does not replace in-person care.
What is the evidence for telemedicine in mental health care?
There is substantial evidence supporting the use of telemedicine interventions in patients with mental disorders. Research has found that telemedicine has the ability to increase access and quality of care, compared to in-person treatment.
A review of studies on remote psychiatric counseling found high levels of consistency between remote and in-person psychiatric assessment.
A review of outcomes in telepsychiatry found that, overall, mental health interventions delivered via telepsychiatry resulted in similar treatment outcomes to those delivered face to face. The review also found that telepsychiatry reduced direct and indirect costs and increased quality of life adjusted years.
Studies using questionnaires, interviews, and mixed-methods assessments suggest that the majority of patients are comfortable using telemedicine and appreciate the practical benefit of avoiding travel.
A systematic review of app and SMS based health interventions provides promising indications of their efficacy to improve a patient’s physical and mental health state and increase medication adherence. Apps were shown to be effective when used as an intervention for stress, anxiety, and depression.
How to ensure best practice in telemental health?
Before initiating telemental health services, providers should have in place a set of protocols that should include (but are not limited to) the following administrative, clinical, and technical specifications:
- Compliance with local, state and national laws and licensing regulations regarding the use of telemedicine.
- Appropriate technology and broadband connection, with a back-up plan in case of lost connection.
- Use of clinical judgement to decide the appropriateness of telemedicine for each patient.
- Defined roles and responsibilities for all staff members.
- Safe and comprehensive systems for prescribing and obtaining informed consent.
- Systematic and secure methods for clinical record keeping, coding and billing.
- Protocol to handle emergencies and adverse events.
- Systems to ensure privacy and confidentiality.
- Clear policies and expectations pertaining to communications with patients.
- All modes of communication, data storage and sharing compliant with local data protection regulations e.g. HIPAA or GDPR
- Same level of professional and ethical discipline and clinical practice principles as in person care.
- Systematic quality improvement and performance management protocols.
What is the future of telemental health?
The demand for virtual mental healthcare is likely to increase beyond the COVID-19 pandemic. As technologies and new modes of delivery evolve, the remote provision of psychiatry and behavioural healthcare is predicted to expand further, offering mental health benefits for individuals and the wider society.
Medoment is a new patient engagement portal that securely and seamlessly integrates all aspects of the care pathway, including telemedicine, enabling you to provide optimal care.
RECENT POSTS
- 7 Benefits of Medoment RPM for Your Practice
- Remote Patient Monitoring for Chronic Disease Management
- Can telemedicine help reduce the impact of cardiovascular diseases?
- Can telemedicine be used during pregnancy?
- Can Telemedicine Improve Diabetes Management?
- How to conduct a physical exam via telemedicine
- How can MEDOMENT Optimise Patient Engagement?
- Can patient engagement portals improve healthcare?
- How to choose the right telemedicine software partner
- How to invest in telemedicine software